What’s your magic number?

Here a funny thing that happens when your child turns two. You are supposed to have another child. Like, right away. Suddenly all anyone wants to talk to you about is when you will be having another child. Not if. When. Your lack of a second child is almost a source of anxiety for people, like a dissonant chord that has been allowed to linger without resolution.

For example, a few weeks ago I was in my hunkered down work mode (aka lightening fast typing fingers, wry jokes, case management to-do lists) when one of the house physicians on my current service came to sign me out (cue chorus of divine angels). Let me preface this by saying that I had only known this person for maybe three or four days at this point. And by the way she is very lovely and I don’t mean to single her out here because what follows is a conversation that has played itself out in one form or another with everyone from total strangers to my closest friends. So anyway, a few minutes into sign-out I mentioned my daughter off hand and she asked, “Oh how old is your child?” and I said “She’s two” and she said “Oh, when are you going to have another child?” and I said “Oh, we’ve been thinking a lot about it and we are pretty happy as a three-person family” (note here how suddenly intimate the conversation has become, because any honest answer about procreative plans is not really small talk anymore). At this point she looked a bit shocked and dismayed, “Oh, but your daughter is going to be so lonely!” to which I just said again, rather more weakly, “Oh, we are pretty happy” and she gave me another look akin to the look you might give a woman leaning over to give her toddler a big sip of her Manhattan. A look that says: “Your parental judgment is seriously impaired.”

I have this kind of conversation at least once a week these days, with grocery store cashiers, neighbors, fellow parents at daycare.  Some people react as my colleague did, invoking my parental duty to provide E with a sibling. People have even used the word “abuse” in reference to only childhood which I guess makes me the potential abuser? Which is a disturbing thing to imply over a pile of avocados at the Trader Joe’s. Other people smile and say “Oh just you wait. You’ll want another one.” Which always makes me think of that old ad for potato chips: “Betcha can’t eat just one!” As if you might pad downstairs to satisfy a midnight salty-food craving and end up + 1. Some people talk about how two kids isn’t twice as hard as one kid, it’s only 1.5 times as hard, as if I’m not having another child because I’m afraid of hard work, to which I want to say a) my child is a pure delight to me so why wouldn’t I want to multiply that by two? and also b) I just worked for 30 hours in a row. Again! What absolutely no one has said when they find out I am planning on stopping at one is: “Awesome!” or “Cool!” or even “Tell me more about that.”

The fact is that I always planned on having two children. I have vivid memories of lying in bed as a five or six year old imagining the one boy and one girl child I would one day have. When we settled on E’s name towards the end of my pregnancy, I made a secret list of sibling names for boys and girls. Even during E’s first year I saved every piece of clothing for the second child. But now that E is two and more verbal every day and she can both ask and answer the question “What are you thinking about?” I’m just so excited to keep moving forward with her. I don’t want to start all over again. I want to travel with E and take her to concerts and gardens and plays and support her in every curiosity. I want her life to be full of every vividness that money and time and energy can provide. I don’t want to divide up those resources, even though I know it’s possible to do so well.

At the same time, I am beginning to realize that I need to be able to write in order to live well inside my own life, which for me means blocks of quiet daylight hours and also some time for reading and maybe even an occasional week far away from the quotidian in a new environment by myself. Which has to be on top of full time work if we are to eat and be clothed and pay off our student loans, the mortgages we have taken out on ourselves. All of which is also true for my partner. Right now, the financials kind of work out, the logistics kind of work out, and we are all of us kind of getting the things we need (except sleep and retirement savings but that’s for a later time, right?) I don’t want to tempt the gods by saying it out loud, but there’s enough joy in our household to balance out the stress, even during residency. While one of us does the dishes, the other of us has a dance party or does alphabet puzzles in the living room with E. Then we switch and one of us does bathtime while the other catches up on work email. Adding another person to the  mix seems like asking too much of ourseves and the universe. Then there’s the matter of my destroyed post-pregnancy sacroilliac joint and the pain of every step for the last two years and the possibility of that getting even worse….. It just gives a person pause.

I am sad for E that she might not have the potentially good experiene of having a sibling but I think it is important to acknowledge that when it comes to that experience there are no guarantees. I know people with siblings for whom their sibling relationship is one of the core narrratives of their lives and people who haven’t spoken to their siblings in twenty years. I know people who have great relationships with their siblings, neutral relationships with their siblings, and some sad examples of horribly acrimonious and damaging sibling relationships. People often invoke the importance of siblings in the care of elderly parents and yet I know many people with siblings who have still shouldered the lion’s share of the care of their aging parents, whether due to geography, preference, or family politics. Having a sibling is no guarantee of fellowship in life’s struggles and the absence of a sibling does not preclude experiences of intense mutual commitment and support with spouses, friends, and other relatives.

But I didn’t set out here to defend my decision (that is not even really a final decision yet. Check back in five years for the final child tally!). What I wanted to convey is that we should not need to defend the choices we make about how our families are structured.

When I heard on NPR that someone had written a book on being and having an only child, I literally pulled my car over to the side of the road to look it up. I didn’t realize until that moment how isolated I felt. Even with all the diapproving looks and talk of lifelong loneliness, I don’t think I had ever fully identified the stigma associated with having an only child. The book is called “One and Only: Why Having an Only Child, and Being One, Is Better Than You Think” by Lauren Sandler and it seeks to present both a scientific argument and series of personal anecdotes that argue for the benefits of being and having an only child. While I was grateful for the author’s meticulous and thought-provoking research and her articulations of some of the joys of parenting an only child (like the smallest things: being able to call your child your favorite smoos in the whole wide world), I found myself thinking: why do we have to prove that having an only child is better or even as good as having more than one child? Do we need society’s permission NOT to grow another human being in our uteri? Which, of course, is an old can of worms…..

A few nights ago E was sitting on C’s lap and watching Schoolhouse Rock. I was sitting on the bed folding laundry when the following clip came on:

My eyes actually filled with tears. “It’s our song!” I kept saying to my two loves. Which is funny because it’s all about a man and a woman having a baby and that’s not our story at all. But it captures something that is special about our family. It takes all three of us to hold the table up! It feels good to say what I’m about to say: I am so proud of my family.

Three is not everyone’s magic number. Some people are happiest in a family of one. Some parents are raising various numbers of children alone or with people who don’t live with them. Some people can’t imagine being happy unless their family is big enough to fill the pew at church (shout out to my friend KP whose family I very much admire and enjoy following through the years on facebook!). Two adults and two kids is working for a lot of folks. Unto each and every one of these: a blessing!

I guess what I’m saying is: Next time you are tempted to ask someone if or when they are planning on having another kid (or when they are planning on marrying their boyfriend or whether they are dating someone, for that matter), maybe instead ask them: What’s your magic number? Or better yet, what’s awesome about your kid or kids or spouse or life? Have you read any amazing books lately? What is the thing you are most looking forward to today? Can you imagine the conversations we could be having with one another?

What’s your magic number?

13 thoughts on “What’s your magic number?

  1. My magic number at this moment is 6.It used to be 2, then 3, then 4, then 5 and now 6. it is magic if it never changes and will be magic if it goes up! My only regret is that I didn’t see the magic when it was just 1. But it is not a regret anymore because that 1 is more megical by the day in the arrangement of 6!

  2. Thank you so much for this, Miriam! As you know, I’m an only child myself, and it never occurred to me — given my loving and supportive parents, my fantastic childhood, the opportunities and experiences my parents were able to provide me (in part because of my only-ness), and the close relationship I’ve had both with my own small family and all the other people we’ve adopted as family over the years — that I might be “abused.” I do occasionally have people say things like, “Wow, you’re an only child? What’s that like?” (or, better, “You’re an only child? You don’t *seem* like an only child?” — as if not having siblings implies a character flaw!) but from my personal perspective, I don’t entirely get what all the fuss is about. To each their own! There are pluses and minuses to everything! I applaud your idea of finding your own “magic number” — and not passing that judgment onto others, even if the magic number is 3. (As you point out, that’s enough legs to balance a table.)

  3. So insightful, thank you for sharing this. It occurred to me recently that 2 kids might be the least criticized number of kids- no one bats an eye about you having just one or too many.

    I’ve gotten comments to the effect of “You have a boy and a girl, perfect , all done!” I find it both uncomfortable and not a little bit insulting.

    • Hi Katie — yes, the gender politics behind family size discussion are disturbing. If there’s a family of all girls everyone asks if the family is going to try for a boy and vice versa. As if the value of the second boy or third girl is somehow less because everyone is striving for an ideal of gender balance, rather than investing an infinite amount of love into the decision to have another child regardless of its gender. Hope you and yours are doing well!!

  4. I love your blog and check it all the time for new posts. I’m a resident too, married to another resident, and the mother of one child…who will turn 5 soon and has special needs. I always planned on having two as well, but I am not sure I can handle it, for all the reasons you mentioned. Two residents, chronic back pain, being tired all the time, being broke…all this makes me pause when thinking about adding another baby. But I hear the same things you do about how it’s not kind to my child to not have more kids! What I wonder about is, what if I have another baby with special needs? What will that mean to my current child’s well being?

    • Thanks for reading! It’s true that the decision to have a second child carries more gravity because you are deciding not only for yourself but for your child. I take care of many families with one or more children with special needs and I think it can be both an amazing and a challenging experience for the child without special needs. Sometimes they end up with less parental attention, though they can also be powerful advocates and teachers for their siblings. I think no matter what you decide you can find meaning and beauty in the decision. All my best to you, M

  5. Amen, sister. Healthy, happy parents and healthy, happy little one? Sounds pretty damn ideal to me.

  6. I wish people would keep their opinions to themselves regarding family size. I was an only, and I turned out fine — and happy! And not pining away about the siblings I didn’t have. The truth is, in the end you have kids for yourself and your partner because you want them. All those things that people say about kids “needing” siblings really only amounts to self justification. Personally, I think three is a great number. If we end up being able to manage these next few years better than I think we will, maybe I will reconsider.

    • Hi omdg,

      Thanks as always for reading and for commenting! It’s always good (i.e. extremely relieving) to hear from only children who were and are happy! There are so many negative messages out there — helps to hear positive ones!

      Thanks again!

  7. aww Right now Im so grateful for this post, because my husband and I have a daughter and she is 2 years old and we are considering very seriously not having another child, for so many reasons, we are doctors and Im already starting this year my residency so that means Im going to be around less time for her, and with her I’ve been able to experience almost all the things like when she walked, talked or did her first things. I was there! I couldnt imagine not being there and losing all that with a second. So I get “the question” like every week and later I get the sentimental manipulation like: aww she is going to feel so alone…and that gets me sometimes….but I guess that we have to do what is best. And if an only child is what we can have and want to have well I know she is going to be a very loved child.

    • Hi angie,
      Thanks for writing in! I can tell from your post that you still feel some conflict over this question — I do too! But in the end, I think it is better for my daughter to be an only child with happy and mildly stressed out parents than to have a sibling and incredibly stressed out parents. I’m glad you got to be there with your child through all those firsts — I got to be with my daughter for her first six months and even though it’s hard to do residency and be away from her so much, I’m so glad I timed things the way I did so that she could begin her life in the nest of my arms. Your child will have so much joy and love no matter what you decide about the size of your family.
      Lots of luck to you as you start residency!
      All my best,

      • Haha yes Im kind of struggling right now about our magic number…but 1 is winning..and way ahead. But time will tell..maybe when residency is finished and if I survive my daughter terrible 2 years old :p , maybe I can consider. But at the time being I see a family of 3 in our future!

Leave a Reply to whatbeginswithm Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s